TL;DR: Food-insecure households were 31 percentage points less likely than food-secure ones to throw away recalled eggs and 16 points less likely to throw away recalled romaine lettuce, a national vignette study found.
Food insecurity was associated with a 31 percentage point lower probability of discarding recalled eggs and a 16 percentage point lower probability of discarding recalled romaine lettuce, according to "Reactions to Food Safety Recalls among Food Insecure and Food Secure Households", published in the Journal of Food Distribution Research in November 2024. The same status was linked to an 18 point higher probability of eating recalled eggs, the authors — Mariah Beverly of the University of Minnesota, Clinton L. Neill of Cornell University and Kimberly L. Morgan of the University of Florida — reported. The study also reports that food-insecure people were more likely to seek refunds for eggs, and that Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) participation was associated with a 3 point higher probability of eating recalled romaine.
In August 2026, 49% of U.S. consumers said they had changed the groceries they bought in the previous month because of foodborne illness concerns, and 40% said they had changed restaurants, according to the Gardner Food and Agricultural Policy Survey reported by farmdoc daily on September 9, 2026.
How the recall experiment worked
The researchers analyzed 860 usable responses from an online panel of U.S. consumers. Each person worked through hypothetical recall scenarios for eggs and for romaine lettuce in which three features varied: the item's price, the risk of sickness and the travel time to a store. Respondents chose among throwing the food away, returning it for a refund or eating it.
In 2021 the FDA issued more than 500 recalls for food and beverage products, the paper notes, including powdered infant formula and peanut butter. The paper describes the usual sequence: a hazard is identified through surveillance, consumer complaints or testing, and a notice then sets out the affected products and the actions open to consumers, which can include disposal, return or refund.
Because the scenarios were hypothetical, the results describe stated choices rather than shopping observed in stores. The authors write that behavioral reactions to food safety concerns among food-insecure people are understudied, and that the overlap of food insecurity and food safety warrants more attention in the design of food safety policy.
The gap was larger for eggs
Food insecurity lowered the probability that a respondent would discard recalled eggs by 31 percentage points, against 16 points for romaine, and raised the probability of eating recalled eggs by 18 points. For eggs, the study's summary finding is a greater likelihood that food-insecure respondents would ask for their money back.
The authors trace the differences through two channels: limited income and price sensitivity on one side, and risk preferences on the other. Households near the poverty line spend a larger share of their income on food than more affluent households, a pattern the paper cites from earlier work by Coleman Jensen and coauthors. The paper frames the trade-off as one of patience, in which immediate food needs can outrank health concerns.
Why SNAP looked different
SNAP recipients were more likely to eat recalled romaine, but the estimate was small: 3 percentage points.
The authors argue that SNAP participation, food insecurity and low income overlap without being interchangeable, and they examined the three separately. Their sample, like research they cite, included households that were poor but food secure and households that were food insecure with incomes above the poverty line.
What the 2026 recalls looked like
A Cyclospora outbreak tied to iceberg lettuce sickened more than 11,000 people across 20 states and led to a mid-July recall, and a Salmonella outbreak linked to eggs sickened 134 people in 18 states before a recall near the end of July, farmdoc daily reported, citing FDA notices. Salmonella in jalapeños sickened 431 people across 32 states before a recall at the beginning of August, and an E. coli and Salmonella investigation involving sprouts counted 55 cases across 15 states when a recall was announced on August 22.
Awareness varied by product: 74% of respondents knew about the lettuce recalls, 60% about jalapeños and 53% about eggs. Concern about foodborne illness when buying fresh vegetables rose to 40% in August 2026 from 31% in November 2024, while 32% said the same about eggs and the survey showed no overall change in concern about restaurant food.
The survey is conducted quarterly with about 1,000 U.S. adults, recruited online with quotas for age, income, gender and region. In August 2026, the share who strongly agreed that the food system produces safe food declined, while the share who somewhat disagreed rose.
What the authors recommend
Beverly, Neill and Morgan recommend that agencies and companies reach food-insecure households through several channels at once, and that safety information grounded in science be distributed on social media. They also propose two changes to refunds: stores could refund a purchase on the strength of a receipt showing it was bought inside the recall window, without requiring the food to come back, and SNAP administrators could credit refunds to a recipient's account whether or not SNAP money paid for the item. The paper also calls for improved supply-chain traceability.
What the analysis covers
The published study covers two foods, eggs and romaine lettuce. Beverly's 2022 doctoral dissertation at Virginia Tech, which contains the same analysis, reports that price and travel time to a store affected the decision, and that demographics including food insecurity status, race, age and gender influenced reactions in some cases.
What to do with a recalled product
The FDA's consumer guidance says to read the recall notice and follow any product-specific instructions. Recalled products often may be returned to the store where they were bought for a full refund; when they cannot be, the agency says to dispose of them properly, wrapping contaminated food securely. Recalled food should not be given to anyone else, including a food bank or a pet, according to the FDA. Surfaces that touched a contaminated product should be washed and then sanitized with a solution of one tablespoon of chlorine bleach to one gallon of hot water. Consumers who develop symptoms should contact a health care provider.
